Skip to Navigation Skip to Main Content
VIEW LARGER > Rollover Photo to Zoom

Genuine Vermont Cheddar

Award-Winning Cheddar Handcrafted By the World's Best Cheesemakers

Genuine Vermont Cheddar

Award-Winning Cheddar Handcrafted By the World's Best Cheesemakers

$16.95 - $17.95 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Pin it on Pinterest Share on Google+
More information is needed.
Please select:

Our raw milk Vermont cheddar starts with the freshest milk from grass-fed Jersey cows raised on lush, green pastures by folks whose dairy farms have been in their family for generations. Jersey cows are those classic brown cows with the pretty long eyelashes that you see dotting the hillside in Heidi or posing in most butter or cheese commercials. Dairy farmers prefer Jerseys because they produce the richest, creamiest milk with notably higher percentages of butterfat, which makes for some of the world's most flavorful and delicious cheese. In fact, Vermont cheddar holds its own in global cheese competitions, winning many world champion awards even when competing against English and French cheeses. We offer up to five varieties, depending on the season and when the cheesemakers decide each batch is perfectly aged.

  • 1 Year Sharp Cheddar: Rich, yet mellow flavor with a mild tanginess
  • 2 Year Extra-Sharp Cheddar: Robust with a mellow tartness and smooth, creamy mouthfeel
  • 5 Year Reserve Cheddar: Bold cheddar with mature flavor, a crumbly texture and crunchy flavor crystals found in well-aged cheese
  • Smoked Maple Cheddar: Our one-year-cheddar cold-smoked over real maplewood chips for true smoky flavor that doesn't taste fake

Genuine Vermont Cheddar

Safety Warnings

Allergen Alert: Product contains Milk.


This is not a Kosher Product.
1YR-5YR and Smoked Maple Cheeses:
Aged Vermont Cheddar Cheese made from cultured whole milk with enzymes and
salt added-no preservatives are used

Smoked Horseradish:
Aged Cabot Cheddar Cheese(pasturized milk, cheese cultures, salt, enzymes),
Sodium Citrate (an emulsifier), salt, Natural and artificial horseradish flavor.


Shelf Life: 8 months

Nutritional ItemQuantity% of Daily
1yr-5yr Cheeses and Smoked Maple Flavor:
Serving Size: 1oz
Calories from Fat:100
Total Fat:11g17%
Saturated Fat:6g30%
Trans Fat:0g0%
Total Carbohydrates:1g0%
Dietary Fiber:0g0%
Vitamin A:5%
Vitamin C:0%
Smoked Horseradish:
Serving Size: 1oz
Calories from Fat:60
Total Fat:9g14%
Saturated Fat:5g25%
Polyunsaturated Fat:0g
Trans Fat:0g
Total Carbohydrates:<1g
Dietary Fiber:0g
Vitamin A:4%
Vitamin C:0%
5 yr
Serving size 1 oz:
Calories fron Fat:120
Total Fat:11g17%
Saturated Fat:6g30%
Trans Fat0g0%
Total Carbohydrates0%
Dietary Fiber0g0%
Vitamin A:6%
Vitamin C:0%
Percentages are based on a 2000 calorie diet

Manufactured In: USA

Material - Country Of Origin: USA

Rated 4.9 out of 5 by 56 reviewers.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Excellent Cheddar I purchased the 2-year aged cheddar. Although not inexpensive, it's of the highest quality so it was definitely worth the price. It was smooth, creamy and delicious, but also crumbled easily, just as I would expect from an artisan, gourmet sharp cheese. A little goes a long way here ... no cracker needed with this great cheese. Very tasty cheddar from one of my favorite online stores - can't wait until the fall so that I can order some more! June 20, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5 by AWESOME FIND I live in San Diego, CA. and had the hardest time finding the Vermont cheese but having tasted it and finding this store, I will share it with everyone I can. I even turned my butcher on to it. Awesome find... October 25, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Our favorite cheddar cheese Will be making mac and cheese very soon. Vermont Cheddar is the very best. A little hard to find in Louisiana, mostly Wisconsin Cheddar around here, but Vermont is wonderful cheddar cheese. One brand we really loved is no longer available, but we can still get a few choices of Cabot cheese. It is excellent, too. October 21, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Best Smoked Cheddar We get this every year for the holidays. We started early this year. Love it! October 15, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Best White Cheddar Ever! Very creamy, rich and smooth without a heavy consistency! It actually tastes healthy! This cheese does not crumble when sliced or have a sharp acidic flavor like other artisan white sharp cheddars we have tried from Wisconsin and California. June 8, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by very good cheese I have purchased these cheeses for my Mother several times. She loves cheese and said these were very good. I would recommend this based on her liking it. May 16, 2016
Rated 4 out of 5 by Very GOOD but not enough larger weight's Very good tasting, but as the title indicates, not enough sizes (none other then 1lb). I'm sure costs are involved, but when you have A GOOD THING, push it! April 20, 2016
Rated 5 out of 5 by Cheesy We love the soft texture that practically melts in your mouth. Great on crusted baguettes and pasta. March 21, 2016
  • 2016-10-30 T11:50:33.370-05:00
  • bvseo_lps, prod_bvrr, vn_prr_5.6
  • cp-1, bvpage1
  • co_hasreviews, tv_56, tr_56
  • loc_en_US, sid_62217, prod, sort_default
2 3 next>>