Skip to Navigation Skip to Main Content
VIEW LARGER > Rollover Photo to Zoom

Storekeeper’s Surprise® (2 lb. Bag)

Storekeeper’s Surprise: We’ll Choose For You!

Storekeeper’s Surprise® (2 lb. Bag)

Storekeeper’s Surprise: We’ll Choose For You!

$12.95 Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Pin it on Pinterest Share on Google+

What’s in the bag? You can bet it’s something good—treats from your childhood candy store. Ideal for folks who can’t make up their mind because it all looks so delicious. 2 lb. bag. Assortment will vary (that’s why it’s a surprise!).

  • A 2 lb. assortment of candy favorites
  • Take a tasty journey down memory lane
  • Packaged in a clear plastic bag

With our Storekeeper’s Surprise, there’s a memory in every bite.

Storekeeper’s Surprise® (2 lb. Bag)


Shelf Life: 6 Months- 1 Year

Nutritional ItemQuantity% of Daily

Manufactured In: USA

Material - Country Of Origin: USA

Storekeepers Surprise (2 lb. Bag) 3.8 5 12 12
Candy is dandy -- The two-pound bag of candy proved to be a most welcome treat for my friend on his birthday! He was introduced to some delicious treats from America's past. It was so good, he told me, he sat down and ate it all in one sitting! Don't know if I would recommend that to anyone, but it proved to be a hearty treat on a most special day! July 18, 2014
Mychildhood memories are back What fun. I ordered 2 bags. When it came I opened one and dumped it on the kitchen table. Kit Kats were always my favorite. It only cost a penny back in the 1950's. Still as delicious as ever. I am having my 75th birthday in Sept. For party favors I will give white mugs filled with these goodies. I can hear the comments now. What a great thank you for coming gift for my guests. I am a regular customer and now I have added this to my favorites. April 9, 2014
Very Happy with Purchase I ordered the Store Keepers Surprise, BB Bats, Kitts and Banana Splits. I am very happy with my purchase. The candy tastes as good as it did 50 years ago and it takes me back to my childhood. My gentleman friend is enjoying it as well. We are both seniors. March 26, 2014
Old Fashion Penny Candies While the selection of the storekeepers candies was nice, and I can remember them from my childhood, I cannot give it a high rating. The hard candies are excellent, although in practically nil variety, but the other candies, the Walnettos, Mary Janes, Kits, BB-Bats, Bit-O-Honey, & others, are supposed to be rather soft and chewy, but they are hard and not chewy at all. I discovered that putting them in the microwave for 10 seconds softens them up, but then you have to deal with getting the wrappers off, and why should we need to go through all that? March 24, 2014
Fun in a brown paper sack This proved a real hit with my grandchildren, who liked the chewy, crunchy contrast and the different shapes. July 19, 2013
second one was awesome....I was surprised by the storekeeper When I first got the bag I was so disappointed that I sent it back. Surprise...they read my letter that I sent with the return and shipped me a new bag. Their letter apologized and agreed with me that it was a disappointment. The bag they sent this time did have a nice assortment of old time childhood candies that trigger memories of days gone by when you put them in your mouth. They made note that they were now going to make some changes in the storekeeper's surprise so customers should not be disappointed again. Yes I would recommend the revised surprise now. It was a good variety and assortment. July 18, 2013
Penny Store Candy Memories I have looked at the Storekeepers Surprise bag for some time and finally decided to order it and see if it was like the candy that I use to go to the penny candy store and buy when I was a child. I loved it....those memories came back and I enjoyed the sweetness of times past. June 14, 2013
none I thought I was going to get things I like,But not.You do have alot of products I do like. June 6, 2013
2 next>>

What Our Customers Are Saying about Our Storekeeper’s Surprise® (2 lb. Bag) …

"So much fun and so good to eat! I enjoyed sharing this old-fashioned candy with my children and at work. Everyone loved looking through it for a candy from the past. Just a great mix." - Mary, Anchorage, AK